Thermostat settings that actually change the bill

How this page is funded: No affiliate relationship is in place. Nothing on this page earns this site a commission. Every figure here is computed from the published data in Sources, by the method shown in full. More

The one rule that holds everywhere

Energy use scales with the temperature difference you are maintaining against outside. Every degree you move the setpoint towards the outdoor temperature is worth roughly 3–5% of that end use. This is why setback works at all, and it is the only part of thermostat advice that is true for every system.

Applied to central air conditioning at $421 a year, using the midpoint of the 3–5% rule.
Setpoint moved by	Energy saved	Saving	New cost
1°F	4%	$17	$404
2°F	8%	$34	$387
3°F	12%	$51	$370
4°F	16%	$67	$354

Setback: right for furnaces, complicated for heat pumps

For a gas furnace or resistance heat, deep setback is straightforwardly good. The house loses heat more slowly when it is cooler, you burn nothing while it coasts, and the recovery costs less than the coasting saved. Set it back whenever the house is empty or asleep.

For a heat pump it is not that simple, and this is where most advice goes wrong. A large setback means a large recovery, and a heat pump asked to climb several degrees quickly will call for its backup resistance element — which uses roughly three times the electricity per unit of heat. It is entirely possible to set back a heat pump and increase your bill.

The size of that mistake: heating a home with a working heat pump costs about $423 a season on our assumptions. The same heat delivered by resistance elements is about $1,653. Every hour the strip heat runs unnecessarily is billed at the second rate.

Modest setback is the heat-pump answer

Limit setback to about 2°F rather than 8°F, so the recovery never needs the backup element.
Use a thermostat with adaptive or intelligent recovery, which starts the climb early and gently instead of late and hard.
Lock out the auxiliary heat above the system’s balance point — typically somewhere around 35°F, and your installer can tell you where yours is.
Check whether the thermostat has an “emergency heat” mode and make sure nobody has left it switched on. People flip it during a cold snap and forget.

Cooling: the setpoint beats the equipment

A ceiling fan lets most people accept a setpoint about 4°F higher for the same comfort, because moving air across skin does the work. At $9.77 a year against $421 for the air conditioning, that trade is close to free — provided you switch the fan off when you leave the room, since it cools people and not rooms.

What a setback is actually worth

Setback saves in proportion to how long it runs and how deep it goes. The table below applies the 3–5% per degree rule to overnight and daytime setbacks, on the electric heating figure this site uses.

Applied to $423 a year of heat-pump heating at 18.34¢/kWh, using the midpoint of the 3–5% rule and scaling by the share of the day the setback is in force.
Setback	Heating energy saved	Saved a year	New heating cost
2°F, overnight only (8 h)	3%	$11	$412
2°F, nights and workdays (16 h)	5%	$23	$400
4°F, overnight only (8 h)	5%	$23	$400
4°F, nights and workdays (16 h)	11%	$45	$378
6°F, overnight only (8 h)	8%	$34	$389
6°F, nights and workdays (16 h)	16%	$68	$355

The balance point, and why it decides your winter bill

A heat pump’s output falls as it gets colder while the house’s demand rises. The outdoor temperature where those two curves cross is the balance point: above it the heat pump alone holds the house, below it something else must make up the difference. For a modern cold-climate unit that is often somewhere around 5–25°F; for an older one it can be 35–40°F.

Two settings follow from it, and both are worth confirming with whoever installed the system. The auxiliary heat should be locked out above the balance point, so it cannot engage on a mild evening. And the thermostat should know it is driving a heat pump, so it recovers gradually rather than treating a temperature gap as an emergency. Getting these wrong does not produce a fault or a warning — it produces a larger bill, three months later.

What does not work

Cranking it further to get there faster. A thermostat is a switch, not a throttle. Setting it to 62°F does not cool the room more quickly than setting it to 72°F; it just overshoots and wastes the difference.
Closing vents in unused rooms. On a ducted system this raises static pressure, which reduces airflow across the coil and can cost more than it saves. Zoning is a system design, not a vent you can close.
Leaving cooling on a fixed setpoint all summer “because cycling is expensive”. This is the furnace advice applied to the wrong system, and it is not true for either.

Questions

What temperature should I actually set?

The Department of Energy’s usual guidance is 68°F in winter while you are home and awake, and 78°F in summer, with setback when the house is empty. Those are starting points, not rules — the saving comes from the size of the setback and the hours it runs, not from hitting a specific number.

Is it cheaper to leave the heating on low all day?

No, for a furnace or resistance heat. A cooler house loses heat more slowly, so coasting always saves more than the recovery costs. For a heat pump the answer is closer to yes, because the recovery may engage backup heat — which is a reason to use a small setback rather than none.

Do smart thermostats really save money?

The saving comes from the schedule being followed, not from the device being clever, and a well-programmed cheap thermostat matches an expensive one. What genuinely earns the money on a heat pump is auxiliary-heat lockout and adaptive recovery, which most basic thermostats do not have.

All guides · How the figures are computed · Break down your own bill